![]() |
| Moana |
The film "Moana" disappoints critics... Why did the live-action version fail?
Since its release in American cinemas on July 10, the live-action version of "Moana" has faced a wide wave of criticism, despite being based on one of the most successful animated films in Disney's history.
Many critics believe that the new version did not provide any justification for remaking the film, and its ratings have declined significantly compared to the original work.
The film received a 36% rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on dozens of critical reviews, a lower percentage than even the live-action version of "Snow White," which was also widely criticized and ended up with a 39% rating.
Unlike the controversy surrounding Snow White due to the casting and visual design of some characters, the criticism directed at Moana focused on artistic and creative aspects, despite the new version's adherence to the original story and Dwayne Johnson's return to portray Maui, in addition to retaining most of the songs and events that the audience knew from the 2016 film.
Although the story itself was behind the great success of the original version, which garnered 95% of critics' ratings and 89% of audience ratings, that was not enough to save the live-action version from criticism.
In contrast, Disney recently succeeded in re-releasing the film “Lilo & Stitch,” which grossed over a billion dollars and received positive reviews from critics and the public, increasing comparisons between the two experiences.
Digital personalities have lost their appeal
Many critics felt that the non-human characters, which were one of the most prominent elements of the cartoon's success, lost much of their charm after being transformed into realistic digital models.
They pointed out that characters like the rooster "Hehe," the pig "Bua," and the giant crab "Tamato" no longer had the same presence. Some reviewers described their design as visually uncomfortable, while others felt that they had lost the spirit that the audience loved in the original version.
The acting did not convey the spirit of the film
Catherine Lagaia's performance as Moana received particular praise, along with Rena Owen's role as Grandma Tala, but the rest of the cast did not receive the same level of acclaim.
Critics felt that the dialogues appeared rigid and lifeless, with a clear reliance on exchanging sentences in a mechanical way, which affected the emotional aspect that characterized the cartoon film.
Visual effects overshadowed the realistic style
One of the most prominent observations that was repeated in the reviews was the film's heavy reliance on digital effects, to the point that in many of its scenes it seemed closer to an animated film than a live-action film.
Some critics also felt that Maui's transformation scenes, as well as a number of key shots, were less convincing compared to what the original version offered.
This revived the debate about the feasibility of producing a live-action version that relies primarily on graphics and digital effects, a debate that previously accompanied the film "The Lion King".
Dwayne Johnson did not deliver "Maui" as expected
Although Dwayne Johnson was one of the main reasons for the audience's enthusiasm for the film after his previous success in voice acting for the character, many critics felt that his appearance in front of the camera did not achieve the same effect.
They pointed out that relying on his usual appearance with some cosmetic modifications did not give the character the vitality that distinguished it in the cartoon version, and that the acting and singing performance seemed less enthusiastic compared to the original film.
The absence of any new additions to the story
A large number of critics believe that the main problem lies in the lack of a convincing reason to remake the film, as the script retained most of the details of the original version, with a clear match in many scenes.
Critical reviews confirmed that the work did not offer a different vision or additions that warranted a retelling of the story, especially since the original film is still relatively recent and was released less than a decade ago.
The criticism directed at "Moana" reinforces the growing belief among some critics that remakes of animated films are primarily aimed at generating financial returns, rather than providing a new cinematic experience.
This view is based on the huge commercial success of the film “Moana 2” with revenues exceeding one billion dollars worldwide, which led many to believe that the live-action version came to capitalize on the popularity of the series more than to present a different artistic vision worthy of reproduction.

0 Comments